Analysis
AUSTRALIA AND INDONESIA: PAPUA, DEMOCRACY AND COOPERATION
by Dr Richard Chauvel, Department of Politics, Victoria
University, Richard.Chauvel@vu.edu.au
The Rakyat Merdeka cartoon depicting John Howard and Alexander
Downer as fornicating dingos intent on the separation of Papua is a discomforting
example of a new democratic Indonesia. It underlines that not all Indonesian
politicians and journalists share the rosy image of the relationship propagated
by Howard and Downer prior to the arrival of the 43 Papuan asylum seekers.
Their robust discussion also reflects the much greater political
and media freedom Indonesians enjoy eight years after the fall of the Suharto
government. Criticism of Australia has come from President Susilo Bambang
Yudhoyono, other members of the government, and beyond. This range of voices
illustrates how political power in Jakarta has become defused. Views expressed
by parliamentarians, especially members of the Foreign Affairs and Defence
committee (Komisi I), and journalists and commentators in the mass media carry
weight and cannot be ignored by the President and Foreign Minister in their
conduct of relations with Australia.
Indonesian responses to the visa decision have been framed
by their understanding of the history of relations with Australia. An article
in the respected Jakarta daily, Suara Pembaruan, had a detailed chronology
of Australian policies on Papua, starting with the Menzies government’s
rejection of the Indonesian claim to Papua in 1950 through to Australia’s
role in East Timor in 1999. The Rakyat Merdeka cartoon implies that Howard
and Downer want to do with Papua what they did with Timor in 1999. The Golkar
MP and member of the Komisi 1, Yuddi Chrisnandi, made the same association:
‘We should not forget that Australia was very influential in the process
of the independence in East Timor. This has to be a lesson for us. The Australian
Government’s granting of facilities to 42 separatist Papuans can be
used as evidence to take Australia to the International Court.’ Chrisnandi
made specific reference to the 1991 Santa Cruz massacre, a turning point in
the momentum towards independence in East Timor: ‘According to intelligence
data Australia had a scenario to make the Abepura riots [in Papua in March
2006] into a second Santa Cruz.’ Following this line of argument, the
Indonesian Ambassador to Australia told the Komisi I that the Uniting Church
in Australia supported the separation of Papua by disseminating information
that there was genocide in Papua. The head of Nahdatul Ulama, Hasyim Muzadi,
noted: ‘If there is involvement of the church [in Papuan separatism]
this is not something new, it also happened in East Timor.’
In its protest note about the visa decision, the Indonesian
government asserted that the ‘...decision negated the spirit of bilateral
cooperation in particular to counter illegal migrants which both sides have
painstakingly fostered in the past several years. This inconsistency will
only weaken the commitment of the parties on this important issue.’
The Indonesian government had detected a ‘double standard’ in
Australia’s approach to recent asylum seeker cases, given Australia
had vigorously rejected asylum seekers from the Middle East. ‘Such a
practice stands in stark contrast to the hasty accommodation given to the
42 Indonesian asylum seekers from Papua Province.’
When Yudhoyono announced that Indonesia would review cooperation
with Australia, he specifically mentioned counter-terrorism, trans-national
crime and illegal migration. In responding to Indonesian concerns with a Pacific
Solution Mark II, the Howard Government might have created what the small
group of Australian activists had failed to achieve over four decades?a larger
and much more influential constituency for Papuan independence.
CONSOLIDATING THE STATE IN AFGHANISTAN
by Mark Turner, Professor of Development Policy and Management
at the University of Canberra Mark.Turner@canberra.edu.au
(Professor Turner spent January 2006 in Afghanistan as a member of a UNDP
mission reviewing that organisation’s current programs and advising
on the strategic directions for future activity.)
All post-conflict states are faced with the problem of how
they are going to reconstruct the state after the fighting has ceased. The
basic institutions of the state are often lacking or are functioning badly.
This includes government departments, schools, clinics, police, the utilities,
as well as the engineers, labourers and equipment to rebuild and maintain
the infrastructure. Afghanistan presents an acute case of state disrepair.
Traditionally the state has been centralised, fragmented and often distant
from a scattered rural population. Twenty-five years of war exacerbated the
traditional weakness of the state, culminating with the Taliban regime which
was largely unconcerned with establishing the ‘infrastructural power’
of the state. Their mission was more selective—to impose Sharia law.
One of the leading aims of the newly elected (2005) government
in Kabul is to extend its authority from headquarters and regional capitals
into the small towns and villages that house most of Afghanistan’s population.
The government must therefore create, revitalise, coopt or modify governance
institutions located in its sub-national territories. This involves decentralisation.
But too much decentralisation can encourage state fragmentation and promote
bad governance; too little is likely to have an adverse effect on state efficiency
and effectiveness, thus generating popular dissatisfaction with the government.
In line with the Constitution, the government has chosen
to pursue the ‘principle of centralism’ while delegating ‘certain
authorities to local administration units’ and increasing popular participation
in ‘the development of the nation’. While this may seem a cautious
approach, it is radical in terms of Afghanistan and promises that the Afghan
state will boldly go where no Afghan state has gone before.
It is hoped that three new institutions will strengthen state
control and promote improved welfare and service delivery. First, Provincial
Development Councils have been established to overcome poor coordination of
development activities in each of the country’s 32 provinces. Chaired
by the Provincial Governor, each council’s membership includes the heads
of the provincial offices of ministries and, in attached subcommittees, representatives
from NGOs, aid agencies and other organisations engaged in developing the
province. Secondly, each province has a Provincial Council. These bodies were
elected in 2005 primarily to select members of the country’s upper house
from within their own ranks. That being accomplished, the Provincial Councils
are now exploring their future role, which is largely consultative and monitoring.
They have no legislative powers but, in discussions in January 2006, their
members stressed their role as the legitimate voice of the people. Thirdly,
there are approximately 10,000 Community Development Councils in villages
across Afghanistan. These elected councils perform a number of functions including
political socialisation, empowerment and participatory development. They are
the means by which the state is attempting to penetrate society at the grassroots
level and consolidate itself in rural Afghanistan. The official aim is to
have Community Development Councils operating in all of the country’s
20,000 villages by 2007.
The state’s program of consolidation through creating
and strengthening institutions of governance at the sub-national level faces
many problems. These range from inadequate administrative and technical capacity
through to the considerable extra-state influence of armed ‘commanders’
and their followers. However, the Afghan state has made undoubted progress
in extending its influence across its territory and is aiming to transform
the de jure state (one that is recognised by foreign governments) to a de
facto state (one that actually controls and administers its territory).
Profile
This month we profile Richard Woolcott,
AC, currently Founding Director of the Asia Society AustralAsia Centre. A
former Secretary of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (1988-1992),
Ambassador to the United Nations and the Prime Minister’s special envoy
to promote the APEC concept, he served in four Asian countries as deputy to
the High Commissioner in Malaya, Commissioner in Singapore, Ambassador to
the Philippines and Ambassador to Indonesia. He is the author of The
Hot Seat: Reflections on Diplomacy from Stalin’s Death to the Bali Bombings
published by Harper Collins in 2003.
Q: When did you become interested in Asia
and why?
A: When I joined the Department of External Affairs as a
trainee in 1950 I had visited Sri Lanka briefly in 1949. Even then I realised
that, with the end of British, French and Dutch colonialism in the aftermath
of World War II, Australia’s future would mainly lie with the independent
countries of East Asia and Southwest Pacific. This belief was strongly reinforced
when I lived in Kuala Lumpur and Singapore between 1961 and 1964.
Q:What are your current preoccupations?
A:Australia must continue to strengthen its foreign policy,
security, political, economic, social and cultural engagement with the countries
of Asia. We have many common interests in the region of the world we share.
After I retired from the public service I was Chairman of the Australia-Indonesia
Institute for six years and in this capacity I worked to widen people-to-people
contacts between the two countries. After that I became the Founding Director
of the Asia Society AustralAsia Centre. In accepting this position, which
was launched in 1997, I wanted, in retirement, to keep working for a deeper
understanding in Australia of Asian countries and cultures, as well as a similar
improved understanding of Australian culture in Asian countries.
Q:How do these fit into the contemporary
scene?
A:Australia’s adjustment to its Southeast Asian and
Southwest Pacific neighbourhood is a work in progress. There is a continuing
need to improve knowledge of Asian countries in our wider community and for
vigilance to combat any recrudescence of racism and religious intolerance.
Knowledge is the best weapon to dispel ignorance. While we have global interests,
our priority must be engagement with the countries of our own neighbourhood.
Q:What are your hopes for Asian studies
in Australia?
A:It is very important that Asian Studies are not allowed
to decline further in this country. I hope that Asian Studies will be substantially
increased and adequately funded in all our universities and secondary schools.
I would hope too that non-governmental Asia-focused bodies such as Asialink,
the Asia Society AustralAsia Centre, the Asian Studies Association of Australia
and the Association for the Study of AustralAsia in Asia as well as the various
business councils attract greater corporate and public support. I hope also
that the government-funded bilateral councils and institutes will be expanded
and better resourced. It is also important to promote more vigorously Asian
languages in secondary schools and universities, especially Indonesian, Chinese
and Japanese. Moreover, studies of Australian literature and art should be
promoted more actively in East Asian countries. All this suggests we need
a more coordinated approach to the promotion of Asian studies here and Australian
studies in Asia.
Links:
Graduate of the month
Like many Canberra teenagers, Joel Thorpe’s (joel.thorpe@dotars.gov.au)
post-high school dream was to tour Britain. When he got there, he found it
grey, cold and rainy, with terrible food. Thankfully, he says, his travels
brought him to Jordan in 2002. Despite considering himself a well-educated,
tolerant Westerner, in the beginning, every street-side conversation sounded
like jihad, death threats and shouting all rolled into one. It was only after
he began to delve into Arabic language and culture that he overcame ingrained
stereotypes and discovered a welcoming, vibrant people with a rich history.
He also discovered that the street side conversations were actually about
coffee, food, poetry, soccer and the weather. He also learned that cultural
ignorance works both ways. Despite a diet of some of Hollywood’s worst
B-grade movies, his Jordanian friends knew almost nothing about Joel’s
lifestyle and culture. For him, this was a first-hand lesson in the importance
of cross-cultural communication. He also received a crash course in Iraqi
politics whilst teaching English to a class of Iraqi refugees and sampled
some of the world’s finest food whilst travelling through Syria, Lebanon,
Iraq, Turkey and Egypt.
Upon returning to Australia Joel enrolled in a Bachelor of
Asian Studies at the Australian National University, majoring in the Arabic
language and International Relations in the Asian Region. After graduating,
his knowledge of Arabic led to employment with the Department of Education
Science and Training (DEST), evaluating overseas qualifications. He then moved
to the Department of Transport and Regional Services (DOTARS), working in
the Aviation Markets branch. People often ask him what Asian Studies has to
do with the Department of Transport. The answer is that it’s difficult
to imagine a government department or large company today that doesn’t
have an interest in Asia. In the aviation sector, China’s fleet is predicted
to rise from several hundred to 2,000 aircraft within the next 10 years. This
is a phenomenal growth market. Middle Eastern airlines such as Emirates, Gulf
Air and Qatar Airways are also beginning to play a significant role in the
global aviation market and have begun to express an interest in Australia.
Joel is convinced the language, research and communication skills conveyed
in an Asian Studies degree are likely to be sought after by all government
agencies as they look towards an emerging Asia in the coming decades.
http://www.dotars.gov.au/dept/graduate/
Website of the month
http://www.mansfieldfdn.org/polls/index.htm
The Mansfield Asian Opinion Poll Database monitors key public opinion trends
in Northeast Asia. It publishes polls on policy-related issues from major
media organisations and other agencies in Japan and South Korea. These polls
were previously not available in English or on a central site on the Internet.
Recent article of interest
Jeffrey Robertson of the Parliamentary Library Information
and Research Services looks at the domestic political impediments in South
Korea preventing progress towards a Free Trade Agreement and at the prospects
this may change in the near future. See Time For An Australian-South Korea
Free Trade Agreement? http://www.aph.gov.au/library/pubs/RN/2005-06/06rn31.htm
Did you know?
The British Library has released a content strategy paper.
It discusses how, as the amount of information produced and consumed around
the world increases at an unprecedented rate, the library ensures it collects
material that is important and relevant to researchers. The strategy relates
mainly to international material collected under the library’s acquisition
budget (currently around £15 million a year). A key change is that greater
priority will be given to China, India, Anglophone Africa and Latin America.
See: www.bl.uk/about/strategic/contentstrat.html
Diary dates
CHRISTOPHER KREMMER AT ASIA BOOKROOM 23 May, Canberra.
Journalist and author Christopher Kremmer will be speaking at between 6pm
and 8pm at the Asia Bookroom, Unit 2, 1-3 Lawry Place, Macquarie. Kremmer's
new book Inhaling the Mahatma is set in India. E-mail books@AsiaBookroom.com,
phone 02 6251 5191
CHINA & SE ASIA: Launch of The Paramount Power:
China and the Countries of Southeast Asia 24 May, Melbourne. Launch
of Dr Milton Osborne’s new paper for The Lowy Institute. 6.00 pm to
7.20 pm, Yasuko Hiraoka Myer Room, Sidney Myer Asia Center, University of
Melbourne To reserve a seat, please send an email to: events@asialink.unimelb.edu.au
with "Osborne" in the subject line. See also http://www.lowyinstitute.org
TECH: Competitors or Collaborators? ICT in Australia
& Asia, 29 May, Melbourne. A half-day conference for ICT strategists,
professionals & students. Hear first-hand from Asian industry leaders
from China, India and Korea; understand the strategies of Australian companies;
listen to projections about the future of ICT in Australia and in Asia; Meet
the people who will influence ICT's future. COST: $50/$35 (Full / Student
& Asialink Member) Enquiries: Paul Davis, 03 8344 8474, p.davis@asialink.unimelb.edu.au
11TH ANNUAL ASIA OIL AND GAS CONFERENCE:"BALANCING
THE INTEREST OF CONSUMERS AND PRODUCERS", 11 June-13 June, Kuala Lumpur.
The Keynote address at the conference will be given by the Prime Minister
of Malaysia. The President and CEO of Saudi Aramco, will give the state of
the industry address. See http://www.aogc-petronas.com/
PUBLIC FORUM ON MODERN MALAYSIA, 2 June, Melbourne.
The Monash Asia Institute is pleased to host, with the support of the Australia
Malaysia Institute (DFAT), the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Melbourne
branch), the Asia Society and the Centre for Malaysian Studies (Monash Asia
Institute) an afternoon of discussions about Malaysia with the Foreign Minister
of Malaysia and the Minister for Higher Education. This event is an initiative
of ASLI (Asia Strategic Leadership Institute), Malaysia's leading think tank.
1.30pm to 5pm, Park Hyatt, 1 Parliament Sq East Melbourne. More details from
Tony.Donaldson@adm.monash.edu.au
THE AUSTRALIAN ASSOCIATION OF BUDDHIST STUDIES (AABS),
16 June, Sydney. The AABX will hold its first conference at the University
of Sydney For details, see http://www.buddhiststudies.org.au/.
BLIND DATES & FOREIGN AFFAIRS - AUSTRALIA/ASIA
ARTS RESIDENCIES 19 & 20 June 2006, Melbourne. Asialink's annual
forum for 2006 will evaluate the place of residencies in arts programming
generally and their value for individual arts workers, hosts and communities.
Speakers include practitioners, hosts, funders, academics and commentators
from Australia, Cambodia, Japan and Taiwan. Panels will be interspersed with
an artistic program featuring work made by artists during overseas residencies.
Bookings and enquiries to p.aitken@asialink.unimelb.edu.au
ZEN MIND, ZEN BRUSH 15 June–13 August, Sydney.
Japanese ink painting from the Gitter—Yelen Collection. Art Gallery
of NSW, http://www.artgallery.nsw.gov.au
10TH ASIAN STUDIES CONFERENCE JAPAN (ASCJ), 24-25
June 2006, Tokyo. This conference will be held at International Christian
University (ICU), Tokyo, on Saturday, June 24, and Sunday June 25, 2006. See
http://www.meijigakuin.ac.jp/%7Eascj/
THE BOY and the BAMBOO FLUTE, 18-21 July, Adelaide.
Inspired by the folklore and cultural traditions of Vietnam this play is about
the epic adventure of a peasant boy and a princess, who overcome the destructive
power of an evil demon with the aid of a bamboo flute. See http://www.patchtheatre.org.au/bbfa.htm
16TH BIENNIAL CONFERENCE OF THE
ASIAN STUDIES ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALIA (ASAA) ON “ASIA RECONSTRUCTED”,
26-29 June, 2006, University of Wollongong. The deadline for
the call for papers has been extended until Wednesday 1 March 2006. Please
email abstracts and brief profile information to Margaret Hanlon at meh43@uow.edu.au
Themes of the conference include: the critique of development; governance
and citizenship; labour and social Transformation; the clash of fundamentalisms;
national and transnational legal issues; the role of technology; new and old
Arts; Asia and world history; post-colonialism; Australia-South Asia links.
The program will be posted on the ASAA conference web site by March 2006,
http://www.uow.edu.au/arts/conferences/asaa/
ISLAM AND DEMOCRACY with Anwar Ibrahim, 21 July,
Melbourne. Anwar Ibrahim will present a 30-40 minute lecture followed
by a panel of commentators reflecting includinsg Dr David Wright-Neville (Politics
Department, Monash) and Prof Michael Leigh (Asia Institute, Melbourne University).
6.00 pm-8.30pm Sidney Myer Asia Centre, Melbourne University. RSVP with subject
heading "Islam and democracy seminar" to Dr Tony Donaldson, tony.donaldson@adm.monash.edu.au
BORNEO IN THE NEW CENTURY, 31 July and 1 August 2006,
Kuching Sarawak. Papers are invited for the Eighth Biennial Conference
of the Borneo Research Council (BRC). These should present original research
in any field relating to Sabah, Brunei, Sarawak, Kalimantan and its surrounding
region. Abstracts, no longer than 100 words, must be submitted by email before
1 May to: Jchin@ieas.unimas.my or
James.chin@lycos.com. For more details,
see: www.borneoresearchcouncil.org
RECONCILIATION BETWEEN JAPAN AND CHINA, workshop,
August, Canberra. In August 2006, the Department
of International Relations at Australian National University will host a workshop
as the culmination of online discussion about the best ways to encourage reconciliation
between Japan and China. The objective is to produce concrete and realistic
policy proposals for enhancing security cooperation between the two Asian
powers, especially with respect to their participation in the Six Party Talks
on the North Korean nuclear issue and in the potential East Asian Community.
See www.china-japan-reconciliation.blogspot.com
ASIA-PACIFIC MISSIONARIES: AT HOME AND ABROAD, 2nd
Biennial conference, 25-27 August 2006, Canberra. The conference
will be held at the Coombs Lecture Theatre, Australian National University,
Contact: Dr Ian Welch, ian.welch@anu.edu.au
ASIA-PACIFIC TRIENNIAL OF CONTEMPORARY ART, 1 November-1
December 2006, Brisbane. The Asia-Pacific Triennial of Contemporary
Art (APT) will be the opening exhibition at the new Queensland Gallery of
Modern Art. APT 2006 will present the work of over 30 artists from Asia, Australia
and the Pacific. It will feature a performance and cinema program, as well
as a children’s festival. See http://www.qag.qld.gov.au/apt
MEDIA: POLICIES, CULTURES AND FUTURES IN THE ASIA
PACIFIC REGION, 27-29 November, Perth. the 2006 Signature Event conference
for the Australia Research Council's Asia Pacific Futures Research Network
(APFRN), organised by the Media-Asia Research Group (MARG) at Curtin University
of Technology. See http://mediaasiaconference.humanities.curtin.edu.au
THE AOTEAROA NEW ZEALAND INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT
STUDIES NETWORK CONFERENCE 30 November to 2 December 2006, Dunedin.
The conference is entitled ‘Southern Perspectives on Development: Dialogue
or Division?’, is to be held at the University of Otago, Further information
is available from http://www.devnet.org.nz
or contact devnet2006@geography.otago.ac.nz
You are welcome to advertise Asia-related events in this
space. Send details to: fbeddie@ozemail.com.au.
Feedback
What would be useful for you? Human interest stories, profiles
of successful graduates of Asian studies, more news about what's on, moderated
discussions on topical issues? Send your ideas to fbeddie@ozemail.com.au
About the ASAA
The Asian Studies Association of Australia (ASAA) promotes
the study of Asian languages, societies, cultures, and politics in Australia,
supports teaching and research in Asian studies and works towards an understanding
of Asia in the community at large. It publishes the Asian Studies Review journal
and holds a biennial conference.
The ASAA believes there is an urgent need to develop a strategy to preserve,
renew and extend Australian expertise about Asia. It has called on the government
to show national leadership in the promotion of Australia’s Asia knowledge
and skills. See Maximizing Australia's Asia Knowledge Repositioning and Renewal
of a National Asset http://coombs.anu.edu.au/SpecialProj/ASAA/asia-knowledge-book-v70.pdf
Asian Currentsis published by the
Asian Studies Association of Australia (ASAA) http://coombs.anu.edu.au/ASAA/
thanks to a grant from the International Centre of Excellence for Asia Pacific
Studies (ICEAPS) http://iceaps.anu.edu.au.
It is edited by Francesca Beddie. The editorial board consists of Robert Cribb,
ASAA President, John Fitzgerald, Director, ICEAPS, Keith Foulcher, ASAA Secretary,
Mina Roces, ASAA Publications officer, Tamara Jacka, ASAA Council member.
